I use Walnut Stain pretty much on ever thing I do. So that's a keeper for me XD
If you are into that shabby look I'd go into colours like Aged Mahogany, Forest Moss and Victorian Velvet they seem to be the more 'distress looking' colours if that makes sense XD. I have Shabby Shutters and it seems to be a lighter version of peeled paint so if I were you I'd go for Peeled Paint as it's darker and not as bright.
Good luck it's not easy to choose XD