1. stickles
2. markers (if I had to choose, I think my Staedtler fine-liners and gel-liners would beat out Zig now)
3. Basic Grey papers. Ok, so I've never actually owned any. But I covet them daily. *sigh*
4. My cuttlebug. For cutting rather than embossing. I can't figure out what to do with embossed things yet, but I LOVE diecutting alphas (espec. Olivia) into "puffy" white boxboard, then inking them whatever colour I want. Gotta love cheap fake thickers with unlimitted N's and E's... and 24 other letters!
5. Distress inks