For this one I looked up the restaurant on line and printed out the reviews and then I wrote my own review at the bottom.
“Completely unexpected, excellent food”
Do not let the exterior fool you! Mrs. Mac's Kitchen is the real deal. The food was excellent. We actually went back twice. Breakfast and lunch were both very good. The atmosphere is very busy and different, it is part roadside diner and part beach clam shack. I had deep fried alligator , conch chowder and key lime iced drink - the place looks like a transport café, but the food is great, the service great too.
“First and Last Stop in the Keys”
Fell in love with this place on my last trip to the Keys. Sadly found it on my last day. I highly recommend anything on the menu. I had the blackened fish sandwich which was incredible! The prices and Key Lime Pie are perfect and extremely pleasing. Officially the first and last place I will be going in the Keys.
I never would have stopped at this place just from the looks of it, but someone from the hotel highly recommended it. She was so right! The food was fabulous! The portions were enormous. It was a neat little place with license plates from all over on the walls.
“A restaurant worth driving a few hundred miles to visit”
I wanted fresh fish and Key lime pie during my dive trip with family and Mrs. Mac's was exactly what I wanted and exceeded every expectation. Friendly staff and fun informal decorations set us at ease.
“Stands the test of time”
I just love this place. It has been so consistent over the years. The fish has always been fresh and nicely prepared. Staffer are pleasants and orders are generally turned out quickly. This restaurant is quintessential Florida Keys shabby chic.
We tried this because we were stranded in Key Largo with a broken radiator. This was worth being stranded for – best fried shrimp and best Key Lime pie I've ever had! We timed our trip back home so we could stop here on the way back to Ocala so I could have more fried shrimp and another slice of their famous Key Lime pie! Bill loved all the license plates decorating the walls!