To make clean-up easier for her, I made these labels on our computer, using images of the toys, as well as words. It's very easy to find images of Mr. Potato Head, toy trucks, Barbie dolls, etc., using Google.
This has tapped into Claire's German DNA - the part of her that craves neatness and organization. She actually asked me to make more labels like this for her art supplies and doll items. Let's just hope she keeps this organization going!
(I'm not naive, though. This room will be probably be a disaster in a day ....)