I bought these protectors and overall, I like them. I like that you can buy one kit with various sizes and layouts. The only NEGATIVE thing is that the openings to the pockets do not face upwards. Some of the long pockets have the opening horizontally, which means that your scrapbook paper falls out of the page protectors when you turn the album pages. This could have been fixed very easily by manufacturing the pages so that all of the pockets open at the top! They are made of a thinner plastic than the ones from American Crafts (which I buy regularly). Overall, I love the concept--but it could be improved.