I know it may seem odd but I have both the square and round notebook punches and love them both because they create very different looks to me. I use them both a lot and I am not a big punch girl.
This punch will make a cute edge but I gave it four stars because I was hoping I could use it to add some papers to my Smashbook, but the slots are too close together.
I'm putting together scrapbooks for each of my nieces and nephews for when they graduate. This is a great tool to punch the paper I use for my journalling. I don't find too many tools to use for teenagers who are not into dances or sports, or pink.
Also, for something different, I took a piece of paper, punched the bottom edge and then took a strip of card stock to put below it. (picture the image above but upside down)