This is an example of how you could assemble the topper materials I sent for this swap - I sent half the people some soft, suede fiber and half the people a fuzzier fiber. This is the example for the fuzzy fiber - mostly ran it behind the letters.
In this picture, the letters are not actually adhered down because I needed to send it in to one of you, but for the final version I would pop dot some or all of the letters to make them stand out a little bit. I hope this stimulates your creativity but feel free to rearrange as it fits your page and your style! for 8.5x11 I was thinking either doing a vertical title, or staggering/squishing the letters a bit more closely.
I listed all the supplies below so that you can find matching stuff for your page if you want hope everybody likes it!