Forum > Papercrafting > Topic

Glossy or Matte Photo Finish?

Topic Closed

Nov '11 Twosmilestoday

Hi All

What is your preferred photo finish? Matte or Glossy?

I have been printing on Kodak Glossy but I am not sure I like it.The quality is not what I want for layouts I will have for years to come.

I have a new Canon Pixma MX882 printer so maybe it is the printer I don't like. The printer got very good reviews.

Any strong opinions?

Thanks
Nov '11 Anda11

RE: Twosmilestoday: Hi All What is your preferred photo finish? Matte or Glossy? I have been printing on Kodak Glossy but I am not sure I like it.The quality is not what I want for layouts I will have for years to come. I have a new Canon Pixma MX882 printer so maybe it is the printer I don't like. The printer got very good reviews. Any strong opinions? Thanks

I do not print mine at home but I have always gotten glossy but I get great results because my photo developer has Fuji equipment & I have a Fuji digital camera
Nov '11 Bxr-Linda

RE: Twosmilestoday: Hi All What is your preferred photo finish? Matte or Glossy? I have been printing on Kodak Glossy but I am not sure I like it.The quality is not what I want for layouts I will have for years to come. I have a new Canon Pixma MX882 printer so maybe it is the printer I don't like. The printer got very good reviews. Any strong opinions? Thanks

For printing at home?

I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy.

I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper).

I bought some Kodak paper on sale and was VERY disappointed. I would NOT buy it again.
Nov '11 Lunie

RE: Twosmilestoday: Hi All What is your preferred photo finish? Matte or Glossy? I have been printing on Kodak Glossy but I am not sure I like it.The quality is not what I want for layouts I will have for years to come. I have a new Canon Pixma MX882 printer so maybe it is the printer I don't like. The printer got very good reviews. Any strong opinions? Thanks

I've always like matte finish over glossy, even on my walls.

Barbara
Nov '11 Pugs223

RE: Lunie: I've always like matte finish over glossy, even on my walls. Barbara

I prefer matte, especially for scrapping because it doesn't show finger prints.
Nov '11 Mfelesina

RE: Pugs223: I prefer matte, especially for scrapping because it doesn't show finger prints.

Hi

I prefer matte finish but I find when you put your photos behind the page protector it doesn't really matter anyway. I think your printer would be perfectly fine - I've always used Cannon Pixma but you MUST MUST use cannon inks and cannon photo paper to get the best results. Anything else will look terrible.
Nov '11 Lenethren

RE: Mfelesina: Hi I prefer matte finish but I find when you put your photos behind the page protector it doesn't really matter anyway. I think your printer would be perfectly fine - I've always used Cannon Pixma but you MUST MUST use cannon inks and cannon photo paper to get the best results. Anything else will look terrible.

I prefer matte.
Nov '11 Moxiegirl23

RE: Lenethren: I prefer matte.

Because of the way light reflects off of the paper, glossy is ALWAYS going to appear sharper and more in focus than matte.

I do not trust Kodak. I've been lied to by too many of their reps during camera training sessions about the capabilities of the cameras and printers to buy anything with the name Kodak on it. Decades ago, they were the best in the business, but they've rested on their reputation.
Nov '11 Twosmilestoday

RE: Moxiegirl23: Because of the way light reflects off of the paper, glossy is ALWAYS going to appear sharper and more in focus than matte. I do not trust Kodak. I've been lied to by too many of their reps during camera training sessions about the capabilities of the cameras and printers to buy anything with the name Kodak on it. Decades ago, they were the best in the business, but they've rested on their reput...

I am ordering some Canon paper to see if it makes a difference. I really don't want to return and buy a new printer. I will try the canon paper to go with the canon printer.

Thanks
Nov '11 Lisa Harrolle

RE: Twosmilestoday: I am ordering some Canon paper to see if it makes a difference. I really don't want to return and buy a new printer. I will try the canon paper to go with the canon printer. Thanks

I work in photo processing and find that most of my customers prefer matte finish. It's my favorite too! A majority of my orders are also 35mm film developing. I hardly ever get an order from digital. Makes me believe that digital users tend to just print at home or online.
Nov '11 Aquabunny

RE: Lisa Harrolle: I work in photo processing and find that most of my customers prefer matte finish. It's my favorite too! A majority of my orders are also 35mm film developing. I hardly ever get an order from digital. Makes me believe that digital users tend to just print at home or online.

Matte finish, because I'll get fingerprints all over it if it's glossy.

And while all my photos are digital at this point, I never ever print at home - I upload and pick up in store because I hate waiting for shipping. I've stopped using the Walgreen's nearest me due to the lower-quality matte photo paper they've started using, but another Walgreen's about 20 minutes away is still using the good stuff.
Nov '11 Sneezy1956

RE: Aquabunny: Matte finish, because I'll get fingerprints all over it if it's glossy. And while all my photos are digital at this point, I never ever print at home - I upload and pick up in store because I hate waiting for shipping. I've stopped using the Walgreen's nearest me due to the lower-quality matte photo paper they've started using, but another Walgreen's about 20 minutes away is still using the goo...

Prefer to go to a lab and matte finish! Just like the feel of matte in layouts!
Nov '11 Jaxxan

RE: Sneezy1956: Prefer to go to a lab and matte finish! Just like the feel of matte in layouts!

Matte photos!
I too am a digital photographer who sends my pictures to the lab as well. I only print off the printer for a quick thing like a school project for the kids.
Nov '11 CSMmom

RE: Jaxxan: Matte photos! I too am a digital photographer who sends my pictures to the lab as well. I only print off the printer for a quick thing like a school project for the kids.

I've switched to matte finish. Mostly because of finger print issues. But recently, I had a white gel pen explode all over my scrap room (I was shaking it a little and white ink flew everywhere!) and I had a stack of pictures on my counter. I picked up the picture a few hours later and noticed the ink wasn't all the way dry so I figured because it was ruined anyway, I'd try to clean it and took a baby wipe to it. The ink wiped off and the picture is still perfect!! Not sure if that would work with a printed at home picture but I rarely print at home anyway.
Nov '11 Andra Hoffman

RE: CSMmom: I've switched to matte finish. Mostly because of finger print issues. But recently, I had a white gel pen explode all over my scrap room (I was shaking it a little and white ink flew everywhere!) and I had a stack of pictures on my counter. I picked up the picture a few hours later and noticed the ink wasn't all the way dry so I figured because it was ruined anyway, I'd try to clean it and took ...

I use matte finish as well. I also use Costco brand picture paper. I use it in both my Epson Picture Mate, and Wide Format printer and it works great in both!
Nov '11 Gracie_1990

RE: Bxr-Linda: For printing at home? I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy. I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper). I bought some Kodak paper on sale and was VERY disappoin...
Bxr-Linda Said:
For printing at home?

I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy.

I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper).

I bought some Kodak paper on sale and was VERY disappointed. I would NOT buy it again.

Linda, I wouldn't be surprised if that tip is true. I once tried Costco brand photo paper with my Kodak printer. The printer wouldn't even print properly on the Costco paper. The ink just smeared everywhere. Ever since then, I have only used Kodak photo paper and have had great results.
Nov '11 Gelidy Gelato

RE: Gracie_1990: Bxr-Linda Said: For printing at home? I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy. I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper). I bought some Kodak paper on sale and w...
gracie_1990 Said:

Bxr-Linda Said:
For printing at home?

I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy.

I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper).

I bought some Kodak paper on sale and was VERY disappointed. I would NOT buy it again.

Linda, I wouldn't be surprised if that tip is true. I once tried Costco brand photo paper with my Kodak printer. The printer wouldn't even print properly on the Costco paper. The ink just smeared everywhere. Ever since then, I have only used Kodak photo paper and have had great results.

I had a similar experience trying to use Kodak paper in a Epson printer. The ink did not dry for over an hour, it just laid on the surface.
Nov '11 Msceejay2000

RE: Gelidy Gelato: gracie_1990 Said: Bxr-Linda Said: For printing at home? I print very little myself, I prefer to use the lab (those I typically get in gloss). But when I do print at home, I use the HP Premium Plus Soft Gloss. It's a matte-type finish, not really glossy. I've always heard the rule of thumb is to use the same brand paper as your printer (e.g. HP printer, HP paper). I bought some Kodak ...

You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy.

I use an Epson Artisan and and Premium Luster. It's not as glossy as glossy but not matte either.

I have had excellent results using red river professional papers. Red River is very helpful as far as code input to make their papers print their best with you printer.
Nov '11 Andra Hoffman

RE: Msceejay2000: You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy. I use an Epson Artisan and and Premium Luster. It's not as glossy as glossy but not matte either. I have had excellent results using red river professional papers. Red River is very helpful as far as code input to...

When I had the Kodak picture printer it would't take any other paper at all. The ink just sat all wet and bubbled up on top of the paper.
Nov '11 Mrsdriver5

RE: Andra Hoffman: When I had the Kodak picture printer it would't take any other paper at all. The ink just sat all wet and bubbled up on top of the paper.

I like the sharpness of glossy and also like the luster paper. If I'm putting the pictures into page protectors, then I don't have to worry about fingerprints...except mine while trying to put it all together. I "shine them up" before placing my LO into the protector.

If I want a bunch of digital prints, I order through snapfish, but for scrapping I prefer to print my own. It seems like labs always manage to cut-off edges or the coloring isn't what I expected. Also I do a lot of custom sizing for my LOs.

I usually use HP advanced paper for my HP printers and get great results.
Nov '11 Purplelyisher

RE: Mrsdriver5: I like the sharpness of glossy and also like the luster paper. If I'm putting the pictures into page protectors, then I don't have to worry about fingerprints...except mine while trying to put it all together. I "shine them up" before placing my LO into the protector. If I want a bunch of digital prints, I order through snapfish, but for scrapping I prefer to print my own. It seems like labs a...

I send my pictures out to be printed. Easier for me and love matte.
Nov '11 Twosmilestoday

RE: Msceejay2000: You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy. I use an Epson Artisan and and Premium Luster. It's not as glossy as glossy but not matte either. I have had excellent results using red river professional papers. Red River is very helpful as far as code input to...
Msceejay2000 Said:
You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy.

I don't have a clue how to put in a code. I only get to choose matte, glossy, premium glossy, etc...

Anyone with a canon know?
Nov '11 Twosmilestoday

RE: Twosmilestoday: Msceejay2000 Said: You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy. I don't have a clue how to put in a code. I only get to choose matte, glossy, premium glossy, etc... Anyone with a canon know?

I have since bought both canon matte and canon glossy paper and FINALLY a great result.

My canon printer likes the canon glossy best. Good results.

I don't care for the finish of the matte on my printer. I usually prefer matte when done professionally.

What is "luster" paper? A brand or a finish?

Thanks everyone for taking the time to respond. This has been very helpful
Nov '11 Stick

RE: Twosmilestoday: I have since bought both canon matte and canon glossy paper and FINALLY a great result. My canon printer likes the canon glossy best. Good results. I don't care for the finish of the matte on my printer. I usually prefer matte when done professionally. What is "luster" paper? A brand or a finish? Thanks everyone for taking the time to respond. This has been very helpful

I always get glossy, I've never even thought about it. I print 95% of my pics at Costco, the rest at home. For fingerprints - a simple microfiber cloth will clean them very quickly. I'll have to try some matte prints since so many of you seem to like them!
Nov '11 Elsje2

RE: Mrsdriver5: I like the sharpness of glossy and also like the luster paper. If I'm putting the pictures into page protectors, then I don't have to worry about fingerprints...except mine while trying to put it all together. I "shine them up" before placing my LO into the protector. If I want a bunch of digital prints, I order through snapfish, but for scrapping I prefer to print my own. It seems like labs a...

I used to prefer matte because of the finger prints, but swtiched back to glossy since I find the colours in the pictures more vibrant. If I print old family pictures I do use matte, because it gives them an older feel.
Nov '11 Bxr-Linda

RE: Twosmilestoday: Msceejay2000 Said: You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy. I don't have a clue how to put in a code. I only get to choose matte, glossy, premium glossy, etc... Anyone with a canon know?
twosmilestoday Said:

Msceejay2000 Said:
You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy.

I don't have a clue how to put in a code. I only get to choose matte, glossy, premium glossy, etc...

Anyone with a canon know?

I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong...

This is typically done through your computer when you print. Select your printer properties. From there you can select paper type and print quality.
Nov '11 Bxr-Linda

RE: Bxr-Linda: twosmilestoday Said: Msceejay2000 Said: You have to "tell your printer" what type of paper you are using. It is possible to cross brand and get excellent results but you have to find the code words to make it happy. I don't have a clue how to put in a code. I only get to choose matte, glossy, premium glossy, etc... Anyone with a canon know? I'm sure someone will correct m...

I understand the Costco (Kirkland) brand photo paper is made by HP.
Nov '11 Yooper7181

RE: Mrsdriver5: I like the sharpness of glossy and also like the luster paper. If I'm putting the pictures into page protectors, then I don't have to worry about fingerprints...except mine while trying to put it all together. I "shine them up" before placing my LO into the protector. If I want a bunch of digital prints, I order through snapfish, but for scrapping I prefer to print my own. It seems like labs a...

I prefer glossy as they seem to look clearer and sharper. I use page protectors and I use a polishing cloth before putting the page protector on. The cloth I use is from a lens cleaning kit. It works great.
Nov '11 Andra Hoffman

RE: Mrsdriver5: I like the sharpness of glossy and also like the luster paper. If I'm putting the pictures into page protectors, then I don't have to worry about fingerprints...except mine while trying to put it all together. I "shine them up" before placing my LO into the protector. If I want a bunch of digital prints, I order through snapfish, but for scrapping I prefer to print my own. It seems like labs a...

Have any of you tried the Ilford pearlized picture paper? Costco has carried it a few times, and of course you go back for it and can't ever find it again!
I love the way photos turn out on this paper! But to buy it from the manufacture is way more then I am willing to spend.